Minutes: ASR Round Table April 1998
From StarFleet Bureau of Information
Home |
Star Fleet Library |
BuPers |
SF Engineering |
SF Intelligence |
SF JAG |
SF Marine Corps |
SF Medical |
SF Records |
SF Sciences
UFP Dept. of Colonial Affairs |
UFP Educational, Scientific and Cultural Org.
Minutes
SUBJECT UNIT DELEGATE ------------------------------------------------------------------ ================================================================== Opening remarks CINCSF/Chair Coffman Roll FEYNMAN Catterick Docket FEYNMAN Catterick Closure of Roll/ CINCSF/Chair Coffman Start of Nominations Period Point of Information (Docket) CALLISTO O?Conor Point of Information (Docket) TRAFALGAR Elwell Start of Nominations CINCSF/Chair CINCSF/Chair Coffman Nomination CINCSF/Chair (P.Gilbertson) HERAKLES Groner Official Notification HOUSTON Tripp Nomination Seconded CINCSF/Chair HOUSTON Tripp (P.Gilbertson) Acceptance of Nomination ALLIANCE Gilbertson CINCSF/Chair Proposal (Official Notification) EXCALIBUR Burns Nomination CINCSF/Chair (D.Coffman) AURORA Nicholls Point of Information (Proposal) CINCSF/Chair Coffman Nomination Seconded CINCSF/Chair INDIGO Jenkins (D.Coffman) Point of Personal Privilege CSFO Schalk Nomination CINCSF/Chair (J.Makela) BLUE Sandlin Proposal 98.01.01 FEYNMAN Catterick Proposal 98.01.03 FEYNMAN Catterick Proposal 98.01.04 FEYNMAN Catterick Docket, Revised FEYNMAN Catterick Listserv/Extension of CINCSF/Chair Coffman Nominations Period Nomination Seconded CINCSF/Chair DS4 Forsyth (J.Makela) Status of Nomination CINCSF/Chair CINCSF/Chair Coffman RE: Nomination CINCSF/Chair COMLOG Makela (J.Makela) Nomination CINCSF/Chair (S.Green) 21-MTFW Severance RE: Nomination CINCSF/Chair (S.Green) SUFFOLK Drake Docket, Revised FEYNMAN Catterick Motion (Extension) INDIGO Jenkins RE: Motion (Extension) NOVA Crawford RE: Motion (Extension) 21-MTFW Severance RE: Nomination CINCSF/Chari (S.Green) RED Green RE: Motion (Extension) CINCSF/Chair Coffman Start of Discussion CINCSF/Chair Coffman Question to Candidates ALIGHIERI Muir Opening Speech ALLIANCE Gilberston CINCSF Discussion CSFO Schalk CINCSF Discussion SFFR7 Green CINCSF Discussion CSFO Schalk CINCSF Discussion STONEWALL Harrington CINCSF Discussion INDIGO Jenkins RE: Questions to Candidates ALLIANCE Gilbertson CINCSF Discussion ALLIANCE Gilbertson CINCSF Discussion 21-MTFW Severance CINCSF Discussion HERAKLES Groner CINCSF Discussion INDIGO Jenkins CINCSF Discussion (Clarification) RED Green CINCSF Discussion BLUE Sandlin CINCSF Discussion TRAFALGAR Elwell CINCSF Discussion CALLISTO O?Conor CINCSF Discussion HERAKLES Groner CINCSF Discussion SFFR7 Green CINCSF Discussion LEVIATHAN Speake CINCSF Discussion SILVER Dawe CINCSF Discussion CSFO Schalk CINCSF Discussion CSFO Schalk CINCSF Discussion PULSAR Hydeman CINCSF Discussion VICTORY GANT CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion AURORA Nicholls CINCSF Discussion HOUSTON Tripp CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion INDIGO Jenkins CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion INDIGO Jenkins CINCSF Discussion SFFR7 Green CINCSF Discussion RED Green CINCSF Discussion SFFR7 Green CINCSF Discussion CHESAPEKE Cunliffe Naming Conventions CINCSF/Chair Coffman CINCSF Discussion REGENT Monfortan CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion HERAKLES Groner CINCSF Discussion HOUSTON Tripp CINCSF Discussion HOUSTON Tripp CINCSF Discussion TRAFALGAR Elwell CINCSF Discussion INDIGO Jenkins Apologies ALLIANCE Gilbertson Administration and Branches ALLIANCE Gilbertson Administration and Branches INDIGO Jenkins Point of Information ALIGHEIRI Muir Further Clarification Request ALIGHEIRI Muir Withdrawal of Question ALIGHEIRI Muir CINCSF Discussion EXCALIBUR Burns CINCSF Discussion LEVIATHAN Speake CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela Administration and Branches COMLOG Makela Administration and Branches ALLIANCE Makela Website and Advertising ALLIANCE Gilbertson Website and Advertising VICTORY Gant Website and Advertising ALLIANCE Gilbertson Administration and Branches AURORA Nicholls Adminstration and Branches INDIGO Jenkins Administration and Branches RED Green CINCSF Discussion ENDEAVOUR Cabrero Branches and Ancillary COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion TEMPEST Synder CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion SORANUS Bell Motion to Extend COMANC Rowe CINCSF Discussion CALLISTO O?Conor Qualifications and Time ALLIANCE Gilbertson ANC Fleet ALLIANCE Gilbertson RE: Motion to Extend CINCSF/Chair Coffman RE: Motion to Extend TEMPEST Snyder RE: Motion to Extend RMF-15 Meushaw RE: Motion to Extend CONSTELLATION Bowman RE: Motion to Extend CONSTELLATION Bowman RE: Motion to Extend SFFR7 Green RE: Motion to Extend EXCALIBUR Burns RE: Motion to Extend BLUE Sandlin RE: Motion to Extend CINCSF/Chair Coffman RE: CINCSF Discussion CINCSF/Chair Coffman Apology SFFR7 Green Point of Information REGENT Monforton Point of Information TEMPEST Snyder CSFO ALLIANCE Gilbertson CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela CINCSF Discussion COMLOG Makela RE: Apology CINCSF/Chair Coffman CINCSF Discussion INDIGO Jenkins RE: CINCSF Discussion CINCSF/Chair Coffman End of Discussion/Start of Vote CINCSF/Chair Coffman Voting Results CINCSF/Chair FEYNMAN Catterick Results of Voting (New Chair) CINCSF Coffman Acceptance of CINCSF COMLOG/Chair Makela CSFO Nomination/Opening Discussion COMLOG/Chair Makela CSFO Nomination Discussion HERAKLES Groner CSFO Nomination Discussion SUFFOLK Drake CSFO Nomination Discussion CINCSF Coffman CINCSF/Chair Vote (Revised) FEYNMAN Catterick CSFO Nomination Discussion NEBULA Fontaine CSFO Nomination Discussion HERAKLES Groner CSFO Nomination Discussion GREEN Nagumo CSFO Nomination Discussion GREEN Nagumo CSFO Nomination Discussion RED Green Point of Personal Privilege 21-MTFW Severance Motion to Close Discussion TEMPEST Snyder p98.01.02 FEYNMAN Catterick Motion to Close Discussion CONSTELLATION Bowman Motion to Close Discussion HERAKLES Groner RE: Motion to Close Discussion BLUE Sandlin CSFO Discussion GRIFFON Sears CSFO Discussion BLUE Sandlin Withdrawal of Motion TEMPEST Snyder RE: Withdrawal of Motion GRIFFON Sears CSFO Discussion TEMPEST Snyder Second Motion for Concurrent TEMPEST Snyder Discussion Motion to Close Discussion, Ruling COMLOG/Chair Makela CSFO Discussion INDIGO Jenkins RE: Second of Motion for Concurrent CINCSF Coffman Discussion RE: Motion for Concurrent Discussion COMLOG/Chair Makela Point of Personal Privilege 21-MTFW Severance CSFO Nomination RED Green CSFO Nomination GREEN Nagumo CSFO Nomination GREEN Nagumo CSFO Voting Results FEYNMAN Catterick CSFO Discussion GREEN Nagumo End of Discussion/Start of Voting COMLOG/Chair Makela CSFO Voting Results FEYNMAN Catterick Results of Voting, CSFO COMLOG/Chair Makela Secretary Nomination, Start of COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion Secretary Discussion HERAKLES Groner RE: CSFO Confirmation COMLOG/Chair Makela Secretary Discussion CINCSF Coffman Secretary Discussion VICTORY Gant Motion to End Discussion on AURORA Nicholls Secretary Confirmation Second: Motion to End Discussion on RED Green Secretary Confirmation CSFO Votes COMLOG/Chair Makela Secretary Discussion CSFO Schalk RE: Motion to End Discussion on GREEN Nagumo Secretary Confirmation End of Discussion/Start of Voting COMLOG/Chair Makela Secretary Voting Results FEYNMAN Catterick RE: Secretary Voting Results COMLOG/Chair Makela Reports of Officers COMLOG/Chair Makela Secretary Voting Results FEYNMAN Catterick p98.01.06 FEYNMAN Catterick p98.01.07 FEYNMAN Catterick Beginning Discussion on COMLOG/Chair Makela p98.01.01 and p98.01.02 Discussion p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.01 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.02 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.02 VICTORY Gant Discussion p98.01.02 RED Green Discussion p98.01.01 RED Green Discussion p98.01.01 TEMPEST Snyder Discussion p98.01.02 TEMPEST Snyder Discussion p98.01.02 BLUE Sandlin Discussion p98.01.01 TEMPEST Snyder Discussion p98.01.01 CHARLEMAGNE Suskind Discussion p98.01.02 CHARLEMAGNE Suskind Discussion p98.01.01 LEVIATHAN Speake Discussion p98.01.01 TRAFALGER Elwell Discussion p98.01.01 BLUE Sandlin Discussion p98.01.01 TRAFALGER Elwell Discussion p98.01.02 HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.01 HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.01 BLUE Sandlin (Motion to Send to Committee) RE: Motion to send p98.01.01 TRAFALGER Elwell to committee Discussion p98.01.01 SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.01 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.01 CALLISTO O?Conor Discussion p98.01.01 INDIGO Jenkins (Motion to close debate) Discussion p98.01.01 RED Green RE: Motion to close debate on RED Green p98.01.01 Discussion p98.01.01 TEMPEST Snyder Discussion p98.01.02 PULSAR Hydeman Discussion p98.01.01 SORANUS Bell RE: Motion to Send to Committee COMLOG/Chair Makela (Bill of Rights) Discussion p98.01.01 COMLOG/Chair Makela (Motion to close deabate) Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.02 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.01 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.01 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.01 21MTFW Severance Second of Motion TEMPEST Snyder (to send p98.01.01 to committee) Objection to Motion CINCSF Coffman (to send p98.01.01 to committee) Discussion p98.01.01 TEMPEST Snyder Discussion p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.01 GRIFFON Sears Re: Motion COMLOG/Chair Makela (to send p98.01.01 to committee) Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.01 AURORA Nicholls Discussion p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.01 ALIGHIERI Muir Discussion p98.01.01 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.01 ALIGHIERI Muir (Motion to move to committee) Discussion p98.01.01 SILVER Dawe Discussion p98.01.02 SILVER Dawe Discussion p98.01.01 ENDEAVOUR Cabrero Discussion p98.01.02 CHARLEMAGNE Suskind Discussion p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner (Second Motion to move p98.01.01 to committee) Discussion p98.01.01 SUFFOLK Drake (Second motion to end debate on p98.01.01) Discussion p98.01.01 NEBULA Fontaine Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner (Objection to motion to end debate on p98.01.01) Discussion p98.01.01 RED Green RE: Motion to End Debate on p98.01.01 COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion p98.01.01 GREEN Nagumo Discussion p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.02 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.02 RMF-15 Meushaw Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.02 YAMATO Reich Discussion p98.01.01 CORONA Fung Discussion p98.01.01 SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.02 SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.02 SORANUS Bell Discussion p98.01.02 YAMATO Reich Discussion p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.01 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.01 RESOLUTION Kipp Discussion p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.01 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.01 Cabrero ENDEAVOUR Discussion p98.01.02 CINCSF Coffman Objection to Sending p98.01.01 CINCSF Coffman to Committee Move to Withdraw p98.01.01 HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.01 CHESAPEKE Cunliffe RE: Motion to move to committee COMLOG/Chair Makela RE: A move to withdraw p98.01.01 COMLOG/Chair Makela Objection: Motion to send p98.01.01 HERAKLES Groner to Committee Discussion p98.01.01 CALLISTO O?Conor Withdrawal of Motion HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.01 BLUE Sandlin Discussion p98.01.01 LEVIATHAN Speake Discussion p98.01.01 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.01 BLUE Sandlin Point of Personal Privilege LEVIATHAN Speake Withdrawal of Point of Order BLUE Sandlin Motion to End Discussion SFFR7 Green Motion to Discuss p98.01.03 SORANUS Bell Discussion p98.01.01 RED Green Motion to Appeal the Chair RED Green RE: Motion to Appeal the Chair HERAKLES Groner Motion to Appeal the Chair: Seconded SILVER Dawe Second Motion to Appeal the Chair TEMPEST Snyder RE: Second of Motion to Appeal the GRIFFON Sears Chair RE: Motion to Discuss p98.01.03 GRIFFON Sears Discussion p98.01.01 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.01 CSFO Schalk RE: Motion to Discuss p98.01.03 COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion p98.01.01 HOUSTON Tripp RE: Motion to Appeal the Chair and COMLOG/Chair Makela Start Voting RE: Withdrawal of Point of Information COMLOG/Chair Makela Voting Results for Confirming Chair?s FEYNMAN Catterick Decision RE: Voting Results COMLOG/Chair Makela Start of Discussion on p98.01.04 COMLOG/Chair Makela p98.01.05 Discussion p98.01.03 ENDEAVOUR Cabrero Voting Results for Confirming Chair?s FEYNMAN Catterick Decision (Revised) Discussion p98.01.04 ENDEAVOUR Cabrero Discussion p98.01.03 TRAFALGAR Elwell Discussion p98.01.04 TRAFALGAR Elwell Discussion p98.01.03 RED Green Discussion p98.01.03 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.03 AURORA Nicholls Discussion p98.01.03 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.04 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.03 TRAFALGAR Elwell Discussion p98.01.03 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.03 YAMATO Reich Discussion p98.01.04 CINCSF Coffman Point of Personal Privilege CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.03 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.04 HERAKLES Groner Motion to Appeal the Chair HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.03 BLUE Sandlin Discussion p98.01.04 BLUE Sandlin RE: Motion to Appeal the Chair COMANC Rowe RE: Motion to Appeal the Chair TEMPEST Snyder Point of Personal Privilege RED Green RE: Motion to Appeal Chair COMANC Rowe Motion to Withdraw Request to Appeal HOUSTON Tripp Chair Point of Order EXCALIBUR Burns Discussion P98.01.04 DS4 Forsyth Discussion p98.01.03 DS4 Forsyth Discussion P98.01.04 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.03 ALIGHIERI Muir Discussion p98.01.04 NEVSKY Bennett Discussion p98.01.04 TRAFALGAR Elwell Discussion p98.01.03 TRAFALGAR Elwell Discussion p98.01.04 CORONA Fung Discussion p98.01.04 TRFALAGAR Elwell Discussion p98.01.04 CSFO Schalk End of Discussion/Start of Voting COMLOG/Chair Makela Results of Voting for p98.01.03 FEYNMAN Catterick P98.01.04a FEYNMAN Catterick RE: Voting Results p98.01.03 COMLOG/Chair Makela Start of Discussion on p98.01.05 COMLOG/Chair Makela and p98.01.06 Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 DAEDALUS Balzen Discussion p98.01.06 GRIFFON Sears Discussion p98.01.05 ALIGHIERI Muir Discussion p98.01.05 CHESAPEKE Cunliffe Discussion p98.01.05 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05 CSFO Schalk NRPG?People who would like to move on GREEN Nagumo NRPG?People who would like to move on GREEN Nagumo Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 AURORA Nicholls Discussion p98.01.05 RED Green Discussion p98.01.06 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05 CSFO Schalk The Stray NRPG COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion p98.01.05 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.06 RED Green Discussion p98.01.05 HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.05 LEVIATHAN Speake Discussion p98.01.05 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 COMALB Gross Discussion p98.01.05 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.06 GRIFFON Sears Motion to Expel HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.05 BLUE Sandlin Discussion p98.01.05 SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.05 HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.05 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05 RESOLUTION Kipp Discussion p98.01.06 SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.05 INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05 ALIGHIERI Muir Discussion p98.01.05 CONSTELLATION Bowman Point of Personal Privilege ALIGHIERI Muir Apology RE p98.01.05 CINCSF Coffman Point of Personal Privilege CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05 RMF-15 Meushaw Withdrawal of pb98.01.05 HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.06 CINCSF Coffman RE: Motion to Expel COMLOG/Chair Makela RE: Withdrawal of pb98.01.05 COMLOG/Chair Makela RE: Withdrawal of pb98.01.05 COMLOG/Chair Makela Withdrawal of Motion to Expel/ HOUSTON Tripp Point of Personal Privilege Discussion p98.01.05 CINCSF Coffman RP GRIFFON Sears RE: Withdrawal of Motion to Expel/ COMLOG/Chair Makela Point of Personal Privilege RE: RP COMLOG/Chair Makela ASR RT: strike withdrawal of HERAKLES Groner pb98.01.05 and call it an ammendment to proposal PB 98.01.05 Discussion p98.01.05 CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.05 EXCALIBUR Burns Apology HERAKLES Groner Point of Information ALIGHEIRI Muir Discussion p98.01.05 NEBULA Fontaine RE: Apology COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion p98.01.05a HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05a AURORA Nicholls Discussion p98.01.05a SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.05a AURORA Nicholls Discussion p98.01.05a HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05 COMANC Rowe Discussion p98.01.05a NEVSKY Bennett Discussion p98.01.05 SILVER Dawe p98.01.05a FEYNMAN Catterick Motion to End Discussion AURORA Nicholls Second Motion to End Discussion HOUSTON Tripp Objection to End Discussion SFFR7 Green Objection to End Discussion GRIFFON Sears Discussion p98.01.05a INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05a SFFR7 Green RE; Motion to End Discussion COMLOG/Chair Makela RE: Discussion p98.01.05a COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion p98.01.05a CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05a CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.05a NEBULA Fontaine Discussion p98.01.05a HERAKLES Groner RE: Discussion p98.01.05a COMLOG/Chair Makela Note on Forms of Address COMLOG/Chair Makela Discussion p98.01.05a CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05a CSFO Schalk Discussion p98.01.05a HOUSTON Tripp Discussion p98.01.05a SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.05a CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05a HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05a HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05a INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05a INDIGO Jenkins Discussion p98.01.05a ALLIANCE Cofffman Discussion p98.01.05a SFFR7 Green Discussion p98.01.05a ALIGHEIRI Muir Discussion p98.01.05a GRIFFON Sears Discussion p98.01.05a AURORA Nicholls Discussion p98.01.05a HERAKLES Groner Point of Information HERAKLES Groner Discussion p98.01.05a SILVER Dawe Discussion p98.01.06 CINCSF Coffman Discussion p98.01.05a CSFO Schalk End of Discussion/Start of Vote COMLOG/Chair Makela Withdrawal of p98.01.06 TEMPEST Synder RE: End of Discussion/Start of Vote COMLOG/Chair Makela Voting Results p98.01.04a FEYNMAN Catterick Voting Results p98.01.05a FEYNMAN Catterick Voting Results p98.01.06 FEYNMAN Catterick Motion to Adjourn CSFO Schalk RE: Motion to Adjourn ALLIANCE Gilbertson RE: Motion to Adjourn INDIGO Jenkins Second Motion to Adjourn YORKTOWN Levanoni Point of Personal Privilege Not Seated Trock Voting Results COMLOG/Chair Makela Closure COMLOG/Chair Makela Honour's List COMLOG/Chair Makela p98.01.01 Committee COMLOG/Chair Makela
Voting Results
- Voting Results for CINCSF
- Voting Results for CSFO
- Voting Results for RT Secreatry
- Voting Results on p98.01.03
- Voting Results on p98.01.04a
- Voting Results on p98.01.05a
- Voting Results on p98.01.06
Text of Proposals
- RT9804- p98.01.01 (Sent to Committee)
- RT9808- p98.01.02 (Withdrawn)
- RT9804- p98.01.03 (Failed to Pass)
- RT9804- p98.01.04a (Failed to Pass)
- RT9804- p98.01.05a (Failed to Pass)
- RT9804- p98.01.06 (Failed to Pass)