Minutes: ASR Round Table April 1996
From StarFleet Bureau of Information
Minutes
To the Chair and Members of the Roundtable, and to all members of ASR:
Below is a summary of the business for the April session 1996 of the
Roundtable. I submit it for your information. Included, are the
texts of the final versions of all proposals that passed, other
proposals are listed for reference. Texts and full voting reports of
all proposals are available upon request until I delete them from my
hard drive.
Rosina Bignall
<bigna@lal.cs.byu.edu>
Standing Secretary
_______________________________________________________________________
Special Business: Election of Fleet Admiral
Status: Concluded - Mark G Elwell
_______________________________________________________________________
Special Business: Selection of Standing Secretary
Status: Concluded - Rosina Bignall
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.01
Title: Admission of Kachaira Colony to the Roundtable
Author: Clayton Sears
Status: Failed
Voting Summary:
P90.01.01 votes cast % of votes cast %of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 15 36 28
Nay 27 64 50
Abstain 0 0 0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 42 100 78
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.02
Title: Restructuring of Representation of Round Table
Author: Dana Bremer and Jari Makela
Status: Withdrawn
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.03
Title: Mandatory Vote of No Confidence
Author: Dana Bremer
Status: Failed
Voting Summary:
P90.01.03 votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 1 2 1
Nay 41 98 76
Abstain 0 0 0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 42 100 77
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.04
Title: Limiting Size of Fleets and Task Forces
Author: Dana Bremer and Jari Makela
Status: Withdrawn
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.05
Title: Concerning Copyrights
Author: Karl Wyant
Status: Failed
Voting Summary:
P90.01.05 votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 2 5 3
Nay 37 95 67
Abstain 0 0 0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 39 100 70
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.06
Title: Regarding D-Warp
Author: Karl Wyant
Status: Sent to Committee
Committee members:
Mark Elwell <mgelwell@twics.com>
Rosina Bignall <bigna@lal.cs.byu.edu>
Karl Wyant <wyantk@iquest.net>
Sean Campbell <whytwolf@spots.ab.ca>
Jeff Finocchiaro <jeff@jhu.edu>
Steve Fullenwider <blackie@falcon.gnv.inetw.net>
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.07
Title: Amendment to Roundtable Selection Procedures.
Author: Clayton Sears
Status: Failed
Voting Summary:
P90.01.07 votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 9 24 17
Nay 28 74 52
Abstain 1 2 1
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 38 100 70
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.08B
Title: Postings to the Newsgroup
Author: Andrea Schalk
Status: Failed
Voting Summary:
P90.01.08B votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 14 36 26
Nay 24 61 44
Abstain 1 3 2
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 39 100 72
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.09A
Title: Re-definition of 'role-playing unit'
Author: Andrea Schalk
Status: Part 1: Passed
Part 2: Passed
P96.01.09A-1
A role-playing unit (unit) shall be defined as an ongoing plotline with
five or more players that functions as such as part of one of the Fleets.
It is required that a unit have a person in command (referred to as CO)
and another person deputizing in that capacity (referred to as FO). It is
further required that a unit be in existence for at least a month before
the RT convenes for it to be seated at same and that it is actively
playing at that time.
All groups of players that do not form a unit (henceforth called Free
Threads) will be represented by CINCOPS.
P96.01.09A-2
In addition, it is at the liberty of the Admiralty Council to declare as a
unit, any on-going plotline that satisfies the above but is not part of
any Fleet.
Andrea Schalk
representing USS Regent
Voting Summary:
P90.01.09A-1 votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 40 93 74
Nay 3 7 6
Abstain 0 0 0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 43 100 80
P90.01.09A-2 votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 35 81 65
Nay 8 19 15
Abstain 0 0 0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 43 100 80
_______________________________________________________________________
P96.01.10
Title: CMO/CNS Minimum Ranks
Author: Chris O'Conor
Sponsor: Alex Knepper
Status: Failed
Voting Summary:
P90.01.10 votes cast % of votes cast % of total(54) votes
----------------------------------------------------------------
Yea 10 25 19
Nay 30 75 55
Abstain 0 0 0
----------------------------------------------------------------
Total 40 100 74
_______________________________________________________________________
